Heather Has Two Mommies by Lesléa Newman, illustrated by Laura Cornell
Heather Has Two Mommies
by Lesléa Newman, new edition illustrated by Laura Cornell
Review Copy from Candlewick Press
Originally published in 1989 (1989!!!!) Heather Has Two Mommies was reissued in 2015 with a new illustrator, Laura Cornell, best known for her picture books with Jamie Lee Curtis.
Newman begins her book telling readers everything Heather has two of, from eyes and ears to pets and mommies. Mama Jane and Mama Kate take Heather to the park and bake cookies with her on rainy days. And, as they read her a bedtime story at night, they talk to her about all the new things that will be at her school when she starts next week. There are blocks for building, costumes for dress up, snacks and naps. And there is story time where a book about boy with a veterinarian for a dad, which sparks a conversation about dads. Ms. Molly, the teachers, has all the students draw pictures of their families, which include all kinds of people. Ms. Molly tells everyone that, "Each family is special. The most important thing about a family is that all the people in it love each other."
Heather Has Two Mommies has been a lot of things for a lot of people in the thirty years since it was published. Today, in my library, it is a mirror and a window, and, above all else, a way to assure students that a family is people who love each other.
An author's note from Newman is a good reminder of the negative, hate-filled responses there were to this book and the fact that history repeats itself. For the first time, the Accelerating Acceptance report commissioned by GLAAD has shown a drop in acceptance for LGBTQ people, noting that, "the path to full acceptance is not guaranteed, but in the face of this erosion, GLAAD will work to ensure 100% acceptance of LGBTQ people everywhere."
Lesléa Newman's Author's Note
I wrote Heather Has Two Mommies in 1988 and
sent it to about fifty publishers, to no avail. Finally,
Tzivia Gover, a lesbian mother who owned a desktop
publishing business called In Other Words, decided to
copublish the book with me. We raised the bulk of the
needed money with donations, most of which came
in ten-dollar increments, and found an illustrator. I
contributed the rest of the money, and in December
1989, four thousand copies arrived on my doorstep.
Six months later, Sasha Alyson, who had just published
Daddy’s Roommate, saw the book in New Words
Bookstore in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and offered to
become its publisher.
I never dreamed that a book I wrote that came
from such humble beginnings would be noticed, let
alone banned, burned, defecated upon, read into the
Congressional Record, written up in the New York
Times, the New Yorker, and Newsweek, parodied by Jon
Stewart and many others, and finally republished by a
well-established and respected children’s book press.
More important than all the controversies that have
swirled around the book are the reactions of children,
who, after all, are the book’s intended
audience. A six-year-old girl named
Tasha wrote to me and said,
“Thank you for writing
Heather Has Two
Mommies. I know that
you wrote it just for
me.” Tasha is an
African-American
child; in the
edition of the book
she read, Heather
was white and
blond. Yet Tasha saw
beyond racial lines
and was convinced that
the book was written especially for her. A lesbian mom
told me that her son Nick crossed out the word Heather
every time it appeared in the book and wrote his name
instead. Nick saw across gender lines and literally
inserted himself into the story. Another lesbian mom
chuckled as she told me that her child’s reaction was
simply “Why can’t I have a dog and a cat like Heather?”
Clearly the fact that Heather had two pets was a much
bigger deal than the fact that she had two moms. I was
told that a child with a mom and a dad read the book
and asked his parents with great disappointment, “Why
do I only get to have one mom?” And once after I gave
a reading at the Lesbian and Gay Community Center
in New York City, a pair of lesbian moms brought their
daughter up to meet me. “This is the woman who wrote
your favorite book,” they said. The little girl asked
me very seriously, “How did you get your letters so
straight?”
I have never met a child who had a problem with
the notion that Heather has two mommies and that,
as Heather’s teacher explains, “The most important
thing about a family is that all the people in it love
each other.” However some adults (who forgot the
wisdom they had as children) have
felt differently. I hope that now,
two and a half decades after
publication, Heather
Has Two Mommies
will not be seen as
controversial and
can continue to
delight children
and adults alike
with its portrayal
of the many
different types of
families that exist in
our society today.
The original edition, with illustrations by Diana Souza
Also by Newman: